Search Site
Free Consultation 855-234-7619
 
Virginia Injury Blog
 

Supreme Court to NC: One-third is Too Much

This year, the U.S. Supreme Court handed down several well-publicized decisions pertaining to groups that have been struggling for their rights. But minorities and gay-rights advocates were not the only ones whose future was hanging in the balance ― a 13-year-old North Carolina girl, rendered blind, deaf, and mentally disabled at birth by a botched Caesarian section, also found herself at the center of a landmark decision. The result was good news for medical malpractice plaintiffs.

In a 6–3 ruling, the Court struck down a North Carolina law that allowed the state to take one-third of the amount of a medical malpractice award or settlement as reimbursement for Medicaid payments. The Court had ruled several years ago that states could only claim the portion of a malpractice recovery specifically attributable to medical expenses, not amounts awarded for non-monetary damages such as pain and suffering.

However, in cases where the total amount recovered was not allocated between monetary and non-monetary damages, North Carolina law permitted the state to assume one-third of the amount was attributable to medical expenses. The Supreme Court felt the one-third rule was arbitrary and unreasonable.

The facts of the case at hand:

  • The severely disabled girl from Taylorsville, NC, received a $2.8 million settlement from the obstetrician whose negligence caused her to be born with cerebral palsy.
  • The state, which had provided Medicaid payments of almost $2 million for the girl, asserted a lien on one-third of the settlement amount, more than $900,000.
  • The parents of the girl contested the lien all the way to the Supreme Court.
  • The Court, recognizing that the girl would require extensive medical care for the rest of her life, declared that states could not establish a standard lien percentage applicable to all medical malpractice cases.

The decision is a boon for clients of medical malpractice attorneys in North Carolina and other states that have similar laws, potentially allowing them to hold onto a larger portion of the damages they recover.

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*

Convenient consulations at the location of your choice Our skilled attorneys come to your home or office to meet with you
Media Center
  • Get to know Lanier Law Group with our series of informative videos. You'll learn about various points of personal injury law, and how we approach our practice to deliver the best results possible.

Recent Cases
  • Workers' Compensation Claim A worker's compensation claim where client was doing framework and the nail gun that he had on his waist shot misfired and fired into his right knee. Client had to have surgery to remove the nail. Employer is claiming there was no employer/employee relationship.
  • Personal Injury Claim A personal injury claim involving a bus driver who battered and assaulted two minors. One minor has a possible mental health issue caused by the attack. The second minor jumped in to help, and driver struck her as well.
  • Car Accident Claim A car accident claim where our client, a police officer, was struck in the rear while on duty, by a drunk driver.
  • Workers' Compensation Claim A worker's compensation claim where client slipped and fell on ice, injuring his left knee and right hip. Client had to have hip replacement surgery and received a 25 percent rating on his knee.
Read More
Testimonials
  • “She was very professional, kept me completely involved and updated with everything. Awesome job done.”

    - T.D.

  • “Maria stayed on top of everything with updates, etc.”

    - J.M.

  • “Very good communication throughout my case. Brenda paid great attention to my case and kept me up to date.”

    - T.P.

  • “Both attorneys involved were very informative and walked me through my case every setp of the way. They answered any questions and concerns I had whenever they cam up. I was very nervous and skeptical at the beginning but that quickly changed.”

    - J.B.

See All Testimonials
Our Firm
Download Our App

Our Social Security Disability Help Center app can provide assistance if you've been involved in an accident. Use the links below to select and download our app for your Apple® or Android device.

Contact Us

Please fill out form below and one of our attorneys will contact you.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Our Office Locations

Use the map below to find the location closest to you

  • -- mi
    Raleigh, NC
    207 W. Millbrook Road, Suite 215
    Raleigh, NC 27609
    • 1.(919) 848-2000 Tel
  • -- mi
    Charlotte, NC
    10130 Mallard Creek Road, Suite 110
    Charlotte, NC 28262
    • 1.(704) 341-5558 Tel
  • -- mi
    Jamestown, NC
    4915 Piedmont Pkwy., Suite 104
    Jamestown, NC 27282
    • 1.(336) 855-8554 Tel
  • -- mi
    Greensboro, NC
    222 S. Swing Road, Suite 6
    Greensboro, NC 27409
    • 1.(336) 855-8554 Tel
  • -- mi
    Winston-Salem, NC
    250 Executive Park Boulevard, Suite 107
    Winston-Salem, NC 27103
    • 1.(336) 760-9996 Tel
  • -- mi
    Durham, NC
    600 S. Duke Street
    Durham, NC 27701
    • 1.(919) 682-2111 Tel
  • -- mi
    Greenville, NC
    108 W. Firetower Road, Suite H
    Greenville, NC 28590
    • 1.(252) 757-7777 Tel
  • -- mi
    Burlington, NC
    2630 Ramada Road
    Burlington, NC 27215
    • 1.(336) 506-1041 Tel
  • -- mi
    Fayetteville, NC
    4200 Morganton Road, Suite 200-15
    Fayetteville, NC 28314
    • 1.(910) 484-3333 Tel
  • -- mi
    Asheville, NC
    603 Biltmore Ave
    Asheville, NC 28803
    • 1.(828) 412-3503 Tel
  • -- mi
    Wilmington, NC
    1213 Culbreth Drive, Suite 120
    Wilmington, NC 28405
    • 1.(910) 256-4445 Tel
View more